Talking about genetics
When an individual is identified as affected by, or at risk of, a condition with a direct or contributory genetic basis, the impact ripples though the family. It is the family dimensions and impact that can make a genetic consultation different.
Consumers’ perspective
- A recent study exploring Australian consumers’ views regarding the management of genetic conditions by GPs highlights a number of key points related to counselling skills in the general practice:
- The GP’s role is perceived as one that should manage the patient in a holistic manner. This encompasses the patient’s medical history, their family, as well as their emotional health
- The GP is viewed as a health care provider with whom a long-term relationship is likely to develop.
Given good interpersonal skills, this will allow a patient and their family to develop trust and confidence in the GP over time
- Families living with rare genetic conditions often have considerable understanding of the condition.
GPs need to consider the patients’ and families’ expertise, as consumers can be a useful source
of information
Common misconceptions about genetics
An individual’s physical similarity to other relatives will indicate their risk of developing
a condition, eg ‘My father has the condition, but I look like my mother, so I’m OK’.
Conditions affecting mostly women (eg breast cancer) can only be inherited through the maternal line.
A condition only affects one gender in a family eg when only men in a family have or had Huntington disease, the women are not at risk.
Tests are available for all inherited conditions.
The presence of a mutation means that an individual will definitely develop the condition, even though the risk is not 100% (incomplete or reduced penetrance), eg ‘I have the breast cancer gene, therefore I am going to get cancer’.
A ‘one in four’ risk means that after one child is affected, the next three will be unaffected.
If a condition is dominantly inherited, then the mutated gene is ‘stronger’ and will be passed on more often, so more people will be affected than unaffected.


